Hawk La console du CWAR à gauche et la console principale du BCC, à droite. © L.Schmitz.

From left to right, the CWAR console and the main display of the BCC. © L.Schmitz.
As soon as the night fell, the battery moved towards Mengeringhausen, an exercise ground nearby. It was late and as they had drunk too much the night before, the evaluators asked their driver to take them back to the hotel. Once they were gone, a rotation of vehicles was organized to bring back our personnel to their quarters. Some volunteers would remain on site to act as if everyone was present. The battery commander was taking a big risk, but he knew that with a good night's sleep, his men would work much better the next day. During wartime, everything is allowed, right? Alone in the BCC, I simulated attacks of enemy aircraft all night long - in fact, innocent airliners... The next morning, was catastrophic. The evaluators overtook the column of trucks bringing our men back to the site. Fortunately, the driver of the minibus had the presence of mind to ‘get lost’ in the thick fog that covered the area that morning. When the evaluators arrived at the site the men were back at their posts, fresh as a daisy. I needed to sleep for a few hours. I had bought a ‘Bivibag’ from the British Army, a Gore-Tex shelter making it possible to sleep anywhere. In order to protect me from the rain, while remaining nearby, I lay down under the truck carrying the BCC. The place was horribly noisy, so I slept with my hearing protections. A disturbing silence suddenly woke me up. Above me, the truck was gone. It was moved during my sleep and with the fog, no one saw me. Fortunately, I had not been crushed and the battery was not very far. I could hear the hum of a generator somewhere on my right.

Hawk Le BCC était plutôt exigu. © L.Schmitz.

The BCC was rather cramped. © L.Schmitz.
At night, the amazed evaluators watched the arrival of a taxi being towed by one of our missile loading vehicles in order not to get stuck in the mud. The German driver was transporting 87 hot pizzas and a can of beer per person, while the evaluators had to content with their combat rations and a can of coke. I turned towards an American officer: “Would you like a slice of pizza? Help yourself, there’s plenty left”. The major sat next to me to enjoy his ‘Cappricciosa’ and a Jupiler beer. “You guys are unbelievable!”. Inside the BCC my BCA was copying a secret list with incidents, which the Yank had left on his chair. It was war, wasn’t it? A chemical attack surprised us at dawn. Wearing a gas mask even with a cartridge filter emptied of its content is not comfortable. Just try to speak on the radio with that thing over your face! Moreover, the BCC was crowded. The 3 by 2 meters large container hosted 7 people and their working stations: the BCO, the BCA, the two HPIR operators, the CWAR operator, a soldier who made the liaison with the PC and moreover, the American evaluator. Well, at least nobody was smoking… Bad luck: the PAR went suddenly unserviceable and we had to move it away. We received another one, but while we were assembling it, we found out that we had received two left reflectors… Followed a great palaver with the chief repairman. The American was already noting on a form that the battery was not operational. In times of hardship, you have to make do with what you have! I decided to run the radar with only a half antenna. The predictions went full swing: some thought that the radar would turn over immediately; others thought that it would twist. The majority thought that the vibrations would prevent a normal detection. The radar took finally its twenty turns per minute without problems in front of a speechless evaluator. An echo at 85 km indicated that it was working rather well and the combat resumed again. The vexed American corrected his form and shook his head: “you guys are incredible!”… Shortly after, the war was over. Once again, the Alpha battery had saved the free world. It was rewarded with an ‘Excellent’, and the battalion received a global ‘Satisfactory’ score.

Playing cat and mouse

Hawk Chaque batterie possédait quelques affûts AA triples. Ces antiques canons Hispano de 20mm à chargeurs "tambour" étaient destinés à la défense rapprochée des sites. Lors des "taceval" la batterie Alpha simulait des canons supplémentaires à l'aide de tubes destinés normalement à lever les filets de camouflage. Un leurre aussi bon marché qu'efficace! © Collection M.Wyffels.

Each Hawk battery was equipped with old Hispano 20mm guns for close protection. © M.Wyffels collection.
Spring is not only the season for little birds, but also for airmen of all kinds. After months of reduced activity due to the weather, they must make up for the lost time and build up hours. Each day the F-16, F-18 and Mirage were simulating attacks on the site. This morning for example, Lynx helicopters from Paderborn were attacking us. Of course, we shot down all of them. Too easy: the HPIR detected the rotation of their rotor dsics without any problem. You could shot them even before they took off! Sometimes, the Russians woke up. Between Kassel and Leipzig, the border formed a corner planted in West Germany. Sometimes the MiG-25 patrol launched at Mach 2 along the Iron Curtain cut the corner for a few seconds. Perestroika or not, the Soviet Army remained a formidable opponent and it intended to remind it to us from time to time. Periodically, the NATO CRC (Command and Reporting Center) sent us a ‘Zombie Warning’. A ‘Zombie’ was a civilian aircraft suspected of being equipped with electronic spying equipment. We then avoided activating the radar in order not to reveal our frequencies, even if the rumor went that the Soviets knew the Hawk better than us! A colleague told me that in 1987, the radar site at Oesdorf (Charlie battery) was jammed by a strange noise coming from a point nearby in West Germany. After several hours, the firing officer drove with a jeep to the suspected coordinates. To his surprise, the place was a parking place along the Autobahn Dortmund-Kassel. A large semi-trailer equipped with ‘TIR’ plates had been parked there for several days, which had also aroused the suspicions of the maintenance crews. The electronic jamming ceased on the arrival of the Polizei and security officers. The truck was then escorted back to East Germany (1).

Hawk ‘Reds’ were not the only one to try to jam us. US EF-111 ECM aircraft sometimes sent ‘Music’ to our antennas but with only a limited success. The ECCM equipments of the Hawk were very efficient. The fighter aircraft threw aluminum strips (chaff) that had absolutely no effect. However, one aircraft seemed really capable of making us blind: the B-52. I have never witnessed it myself, but colleagues assured me that its effects were spectacular. It was always possible to fire in the ‘Home on Jam’ mode, but other targets were then hidden. One summer evening, while the operators were training on airliners, an echo appeared at the north edge of the screen, away from traditional airways. Already at the second revolution of the radar it was clear that this was not a normal customer. Both spots were very distant from each other and the firing computer designated the object as ‘Cat One’... This aircraft was now the greatest threat to the battery even if it was more than a hundred kilometers away. The first High-Power locked at a distance of 80 kilometers: "Alpha Skin Lock; Velocity Very High; Flight Level ... gosh!". On my indicator, the needle was stuck at the top of the graduations. The target had to be at 30.000 meters. It flew incredibly fast and the radar was locked on its fuselage instead of the blades of the reactor fans. The ‘PIP’ (Predicted Intercept Point) already exceeded the battery: it was now almost impossible to fire. We observed the unusual aircraft crossing the screen from north to south in a few antenna revolutions. Its speed was much higher than that of an anti-radiation missile and the echo on the ‘Velocity Scope’ of the High Power floated to the far right near 4.000km/h! At that time, the SR-71 spy plane was the only aircraft capable of such a performance. We watched the sky in vain as no vapor trail betrayed the passage of the mysterious aircraft in the stratosphere... (see > Intercepting the blackbird).

Hawk belt La zone couverte par les deux bataillons belges (43A en mauve et 62A en turquoise) était considérable. Il s'agit ici d'une situation temps de paix avec seulement deux sites actifs. En temps de guerre, trois sites (quatre avant 1979) étaient actifs par bataillon, mais comme ils étaient situés dans une même zone, la superficie couverte n'était guère plus grande que celle représentée ici.

The area covered by the two Belgian Hawk battalions (43A in purple and 62A in turquoise) was considerable. This is a peacetime situation with only two sites actives. In case of war, three sites (four before 1979) would have been active for each battalion. As they were located in a same area, the area covered would have been nearly the same as shown here.
Since the Battle of Britain, the airmen think that flying low is enough to avoid being detected. Unfortunately for them, this is only true for primitive radars, whose beam must be pointed to the sky in order to avoid the echoes from ‘Ground Clutter’. For modern radars, anything that moves is picked up, regardless of its altitude. Worse still, the firing computer always assigns a higher threat level to a plane flying close to the ground. Unless you hide behind an impenetrable object (hill, mountain terrain) flying at low level only makes you suspicious. You are also very vulnerable to short-range weapons. Another myth is that if two planes constantly cross their path while approaching a radar, they can not be shot down. This tactic called ‘Cobra’ and often used by the A-10 was absolutely futile. To enter ‘Zero Doppler’ conditions, an aircraft must have a zero approach speed relative to the radar. This only happens when the aircraft remains at a constant distance from the radar. In that case, it is actually impossible to get a ‘Lock’. But this is not necessary as the attacker is not a threat at all as it is not approaching. Moreover, when it is in ‘Zero Doppler’ for a radar it is most likely in a favorable position for the other batteries. A SAM defense always included at least three batteries. And even if only one tracking radar was available, the ‘Cobra’ could only fool a newbie operator. Any expert would switch to manual mode and continue to follow the target despite its evading maneuvers. In automatic mode, the radar switched from one aircraft to the other.

Hawk The missile would have been forced to slalom, but would have approached close enough anyway. Better yet, the two attackers would have been victims of the same missile, as they flew too close to each other. To my knowledge, the only efficient tactic was successfully used once by Canadians F/A-18. To avoid the detection of cars on the German motorways, the radars were usually set to ignore anything that moved at less than 160km/h. Two Canadian pilots were able to approach our battery ‘incognito’, flying with landing gear and flaps down at low speed. When they reached Arolsen area, they banked towards the battery and simulated the firing of two HARM missiles: not seen, not caught! This maneuver was intelligent, but unrealistic because in time of war an F-18 flying with its nose up at low speed would have been an excellent target for ground troops. The young Mathias Rust used the same trick to land his Cessna 152 on the Red Square, after 800 km of slow flying through Soviet defenses.

>The Hawk missile<


(1) The East German international road transport company Deutrans was known to serve as a cover for espionnage activities in the West. One of their vehicles was very likely involved in the incident mentioned here. Deutrans fleet in pictures here.
In 1972, an ECM ‘Smalta’ system especially developed to counter the Hawk missile and intended to be embarked by Mi-8SMV helicopters (introduced into service the following year) was briefly deployed on the ground to the Syrian side of the demilitarized zone separating Syria and Israel. The complex was deployed on high grounds overlooking the entrance to the Bekaa Valley. An Israeli Hawk battery protected the valley against the frequent incursions of Syrian aircraft. The Soviet operators of the Smalta system were waiting for a Hawk to be fired to start the jamming of its radars. The missile finally hit the ground or was destroyed by it self-destruction system (this information needs yet to be verified).
It is quite likely that the semi-trailer referred to above also housed a ‘Smalta’ complex. This system had some very small squared antennas (about the size of a Mi-8 cabin window) that would have been easy to hide behind dielectric panels located on the sides of the trailer. HM.

NATO UNCLASSIFIED Le contenu de cet article est basé sur des sources appartenant au domaine public et ne comporte aucun renseignement actuellement classifié.

The content of this article is based on sources in the public domain and it contains no currently classified information.

 The Hawk batteries  < Part 1   < Part 2   < Part 3   < Part 4

previous Plan du site - Sitemap next